The Future State of Our Scholarly Publishing Distributors

Final week, David Crotty wrote about “Market Consolidation and the Demise of the Independently Publishing Research Society” wherein he described the shortly converging panorama of society publishers. These societies usually are not merging collectively, per se, however quite merging with a really small group of economic publishers.

David argues that these partnerships have accelerated in the previous few years over pressures felt by society publishers to adjust to difficult necessities of Plan S and different funder insurance policies. This was nicely predicted and actually astounding given the underwhelming variety of signatories to Plan S.

Since Plan S was introduced, there have been predictions that it might embolden and make bigger the largest of economic publishers. Whether or not this was a characteristic or a bug remains to be being debated.

A Rock and A Hard Place Direction Sign

As David identified in his put up, smaller publishers and society publishers fear about complying, but in addition the transfer, significantly in Europe, towards so-called transformative agreements (TAs). Very like when “The Huge Offers” began rolling out to market, independently printed societies are afraid of being locked out. How do they get a seat on the desk? What occurs if a society with comparable content material is included in a TA and you’ll’t even get within the door?

These issues, coupled with points round society funds, uncertainty round open entry, and common market volatility work in live performance to push self-published societies into the arms of a industrial associate.

One of many advantages of transferring to a industrial writer is that you just not need to handle (or straight pay for) vendor companies — typesetting, copyediting, on-line internet hosting, enhancement options, metadata upkeep, printing, distribution, manuscript submission and evaluate programs, gross sales help, and so forth. Additional, because of the efficiencies of scale, the industrial publishers are paying much less for these companies than unbiased societies. Having not too long ago transitioned a program from self-published to commercially printed, I can inform you that that is 100% the case.

What does all of this imply for the seller panorama? We have now seen a number of examples of consolidation or the outright buy of distributors and companies by industrial publishers:

  • Atypon to Wiley
  • Aries to Elsevier
  • eJournalPress to Wiley
  • J&J Editorial to Wiley

I’m certain there are others that I’m forgetting about. I’ve written before about the implications to a society publisher when your vendors are all owned by commercial publishers. However what occurs to the business usually when decisions are slim and getting slimmer, significantly when this involves platforms and peer evaluate programs — all large bills for society and small publishers.

One doubtless response is that innovation will endure. In at the moment’s panorama, would HighWire ever have been born? HighWire (now owned by MPS) was inbuilt response to society publishers needing a web-based house for his or her journals. Unencumbered by the wants of a Wiley or an Elsevier, HighWire was an early associate with Google and had tight relationships with the library neighborhood. HighWire was precisely why many society publishers might keep unbiased throughout the tumultuous transfer to on-line journals.

However once more, is there area for a brand new “HighWire”? What are the incentives of innovation when increasingly journals are consolidated beneath only a few publishing homes? With no buyer base, there is no such thing as a funding. A brand new entrant will discover it very troublesome to construct sufficient help to justify monetary buyers. And with out that progress, probability of being acquired is low.

Even if you happen to construct a greater mousetrap, if there are not any clients, you gained’t get very far. The barrier to entry for any new participant appears practically unattainable. This isn’t good for any business and makes us significantly weak to disruptors outdoors our area.

Talking of weak, there are nonetheless a handful of firms that cater particularly to small publishers and unbiased society publishers. When a society’s journals transfer to a industrial writer, it’s unlikely that the industrial writer might want to add gross sales workers. And their use of distributors for gross sales help shrinks as they get larger.

Likewise, the numerous consulting companies that cater to our business will facilitate fewer and fewer RFPs and discover fewer societies that need assist to remain out of the fingers of economic publishers.

Typesetters that cater to smaller publishers are likewise weak as the massive publishers use the most important of distributors virtually solely. In case you are having hassle following the title recreation these previous few years, you aren’t alone.

  • Sheridan and associated firms introduced they’d be beneath the father or mother firm CJK. Then they purchased Cenveo (additionally a mashup of publishing firms of the previous, specifically Cadmus and Mack), all beneath the title of KGL. Just lately they acquired Kaufman Wills Fusting (KWF), supplier of consulting and editorial companies.
  • The corporate previously often called SPi International is now known as Straive, which acquired Scope e-Information and Scientific Publication Providers (from Springer Nature Group).

Clearly the secret is survival of the fittest. Many of those firms are additionally serving industries outdoors of scholarly publishing, which helps in diversifying their income streams.

It has turn out to be much less and fewer sure that medium and small societies will proceed to profit from being self-published within the medium-to-short time period. Their choices for vendor companies are shrinking and changing into much more depending on industrial publishers — as a associate or a vendor.

As extra unbiased societies make the transfer to industrial partnership, the smaller our business will get, which is ironic given the huge enhance in scholarly content material being produced.

Sci Hub