One other Misguided Scramble For Africa? – Nigerian Banks Take Over the Continent

Between 2003 and 2008 the Nigerian banking sector skilled its personal increase. Nigerian financial institution belongings (based on BankScope knowledge) went from USD 18.6 bn in 2003 to USD 84.2 bn in 2008, however have since fallen again on account of the numerous debt disaster skilled in 2009 (the place the Central Financial institution of Nigeria uncovered roughly ~ USD 10 bn in unhealthy money owed) throughout the sector Spurred on by the excessive valuations a number of Nigerian banks established operations throughout the continent with spectacular velocity. Creating wealth from them will likely be harder.

Creating wealth from new operations in new geographies has not been straightforward in Africa. Customary Financial institution of South Africa, acquired the African operations of ANZ Grindleys in 1993 and has solely achieved wholesome ranges of revenue when these operations have been remodeled into giant scale retail operations by way of subsequent acquisitions. And Stanbic (as Customary Financial institution is named to keep away from confusion with Customary Chartered Financial institution), had it straightforward because it was capable of comply with the speedy growth of South African company throughout the continent following South Africa’s democratic transformation in 1994.

Most banks which have expanded globally by way of establishing small inexperienced subject operations, have executed so to help or with the help of their dwelling nation company base. Nigeria banks haven’t any such luxurious, as Nigeria lacks numerous dwelling grown multinationals that may be relied on to help fledgling banking operations.

One of many challenges is the tiny measurement of many of those markets. Regulators are more and more requiring that banks function as subsidiaries, and thus have to have a full company construction whatever the measurement of the operation. Simply flying administrators between international locations to attend board conferences can grow to be a major line merchandise on a small financial institution’s revenue assertion.

Pan Africanism could also be within the purchase line of a number of banks, however intra-Africa commerce stays restricted besides in East Africa. Even then the statistics most likely beneath estimate the extent to which intra regional imports and exports, find yourself exterior the continent and the financing of which will get dealt with by worldwide banks. There’s very restricted commerce between East and West Africa and much much less commerce between West African international locations than between particular person West African international locations and Europe and Asia. EcoBank has lengthy been the champion of pan-africanism however its efficiency has traditionally been under-inspiring, compared to its pan African friends.

To make issues worse, most markets have already got banks that may present cross-border companies and which have related footprints. In East Africa, worldwide banks – Barclays, Customary Chartered and Stanbic have lengthy had regional footprints. Extra lately KCB and DTB have ambitions to grow to be regional banks, and have created illustration throughout many of the international locations, supported by a robust dwelling nation base.

A few of the Nigerian banks that established cross-border operations already have into hassle. Intercontinental financial institution and PHB have each been the topic of regulatory intervention of their dwelling market. To prosper in these new markets the Nigerian Banks have to outline their distinctive worth proposition, and this stays difficult.

Belief is vital to banking. Though customers are seldom picky with regards to borrowing, the identical can’t be stated for deposits. Banks in Africa should be legal responsibility led, and have to persuade clients that their funds are secure and that they supply a superior service. Nigerian banks need to work a lot tougher to ascertain buyer belief, given the customarily poor repute of their homeland for corruption and fraud.

Many banks in Nigeria depend on Authorities liabilities as a core supply of funding. Nigeria’s federal construction means numerous Authorities deposits at each stage of Authorities and throughout the 36 states. That is seldom the case in the remainder of Africa, which have much less federal buildings, and the place Authorities deposits are usually tightly held by state owned banks.

Fee companies are taking part in an more and more necessary position in banking on the continent. As a smaller participant the phrases on which a financial institution’s clients can use different banks infrastructure is a key driver of the success of a retail technique. Sadly in lots of African international locations accessing different banks ATM’s is extraordinarily costly, whether it is attainable in any respect, and this will kill an rising retail banking proposition.

How then can Nigerian Banks prosper:

– Gross sales and repair tradition. The extent of competitors within the Nigerian market has pressured Nigerian banks to excellent a gross sales and repair tradition that exceeds that of many different banks working on the continent. As new entrants unable to supply scale or distribution, prime quality service have to be the central plank of the technique, however managing service requirements throughout a large community of operations requires appreciable consideration to techniques and processes, and common benchmarking.

– Sooner, smarter credit score processes. Credit score approval occasions and course of throughout many banks in Africa considerably lag these in additional developed markets. A Nigerian “can do angle” to credit score approvals may shake up the market, and will likely be key to profitable market share

– Develop the franchise Throughout Africa, banks which have giant networks seize a disproportionate share of liabilities and income. At dwelling Nigerian banks have been very aggressive of their position out of the department and ATM infrastructure. It is a lesson that shouldn’t be forgotten of their overseas operations.

– Get the segmentation proper: understanding which segments are most certainly to be captured and aggressively focusing the proposition on these segments, will likely be important to rising the enterprise with a sustainable danger profile.

For extra articles or details about Genesis Analytics, please go to

Sci Hub